Today’s SMH roundup:
Firstly, there’s this piece, on gender differences in humour, which I think is an excellent example of the sort of writing that gives the more social sciences a bad name. It’s filled with logical errors – including the common ‘ All truth is relative, except for the truth that all truth is relative.’, although this is more implicit than explicit. Another one is the self-confirming nature of many pronouncements – if you deny them, that only ends up confirming them.
Actually, now that I’ve written that down, I see it needs more explanation. The quote that really shows this problem is this:
the failure of some people to recognise the cultural shaping of perception, and to think that their way of seeing the world is normal.
Here, the assertion is that, unless you allow that your perceptions of the world are shaped by your culture, you are are wrong. But if you do allow that, then that’s just your culture shaping your perceptions about the world such that you think that it doesn’t. But that means that you’re espousing the doctrine you say you’re not, which means that you’re wrong anyway.
I think that this offers some explanation why many people who don’t like the idea of relativism really don’t like it – the position claims a moral high ground: I’m allowing for the validity of all views, while you are stuck believing that some views can be better than others. Because of this, you are making judgements about other human beings without ever having met them. I do not do this, therefore I am a better person than you.
Again, the irony here is that in holding this sort of position, the (admittedly extreme) relativist is caught in another paradox – by claiming a position that claims not to be making judgments about other people’s views, they then are implicitly believing that they are morally superior to others, which is in itself a judgement about other people’s views.
Update: Turns out there’s only one thing I feel like writing today – so the ‘Firstly’ is not correct English. Ah well, the question is, will anyone other than me care?
